Crit is still luck based, but right now almost every fighter needle that I see is a crit. If you would have 100% anticrit the spells deal basically 0 damage and you would get a tankmeta and dps wouldn't do shit.
And because of props (profilepic checks out) I am all the time saying to revert all changes, props included.
The only class I see you complain about is the fighters. Because fighters can crit everything and don't need prop. Why not remove fighters from the game? Never again any1 will complain about dodge formulas, crit formulas or any other formula.
I prefer prop to be secondary sources, it's not Dragon Ball if we keep playing Jokenpo.
I have a fighter and I'm not able to crit like that with my crit rate weapons (I don't even need crit damage %). I love using anti-crit instead of dex. I already tried props, sure 0.5 is a low rate, but even sayin' it doesn't matter that much, even with tankers you can still get an advantage.
If it is to create a topic, unless have suggestions for the staff, a lot can be done as putting a limit on the prop rate, suggest a rate of 3/5 (0.6 - 0.6) although I prefer 1 / 3 (0.66) or giving each class a different influence with prop.
About the fighters, sure the damage is pretty high, I can kill a 10k life points player with only an high speed needle (not super) lvl 1 hit.