Well, I see two competing sides here. One that wishes this version of dbo to be almost identical to the previous one as it would improve everything relating this subject, and another one that wants dbo to move forward and embrace new changes that would seemingly correct the erroneous things that were never truly positive. I personally see one of the most important systems of the game being controlled by randomness completely ludicrous and illogical, which was introduced in the laziest and simplest way possible. Not to mention the fact that very highly upgraded items which only players should work for on their own are tradable. This is actually infinitesimally rare in successful mmos for good reasons.
It's clear where I stand, but I'll remain mostly neutral for multiple reasons. However, I don't think the exact old rubbish system back on retail would actually fix this situation. Looking forward to see how all this feedback you folks leave here will be treated just like in the last thread like this. I'm just here to discuss, not to leave input which would be a foolish thing to do.
Fyi, Daneos already mentioned that he's working on this and already revealed some of the changes that might come true. Funny this comes only now.
Have a blast.